Quick Answer: Metronet Wins for Most Users
Metronet takes the lead with better overall value. With Fiber technology delivering up to 2 Gbps speeds and no data caps, it provides superior performance for modern households. While Att offers Various service starting at Contact for pricing, Metronet's combination of speed, reliability, and policy advantages makes it the better choice for most users.
Best for most: Metronet – Better technology, superior policies
Overview: Comparing Metronet and Att
Choosing between Metronet and Att requires understanding their fundamental differences in technology, coverage, and target markets. Metronet, founded in 2005, operates as 100% fiber-to-the-home, while Att, established in N/A, positions itself as internet service provider. These different market approaches significantly affect the service experience you'll receive.
The most significant distinction lies in network technology. Metronet delivers internet through Fiber infrastructure capable of speeds up to 2 Gbps, while Att uses Various technology reaching Varies maximum speeds. This technological difference impacts not just raw speed but also reliability, upload performance, and consistency during peak usage hours.
Service area availability plays an equally crucial role in this comparison. Both providers focus on specific geographic regions where they've built infrastructure over decades, which means most consumers will have access to one or neither, rather than choosing between them. Understanding where each operates and what technology they deliver to your specific address determines whether this comparison matters for your situation.
| Feature | Metronet | Att |
|---|---|---|
| Max Speed | 2 Gbps | Varies |
| Starting Price | $40/mo | Contact for pricing |
| Data Caps | None | Check with provider |
| Contract Required | No | No |
| Technology | Fiber | Various |
| Best For | Midwest/Southeast users wanting pure fiber | Users in service area |
Metronet: 100% fiber-to-the-home
Founded: 2005 | Headquarters: Evansville, IN | Technology: Fiber
Plans & Pricing
Metronet structures its pricing around Fiber technology capabilities, with plans starting at $40/mo for entry-level service. Their network delivers maximum speeds up to 2 Gbps, suitable for households ranging from single users checking email to families streaming multiple 4K videos simultaneously. Data policy includes None, which significantly impacts total monthly costs depending on your usage patterns.
Pros
- Service advantage: 100% fiber network
- Service advantage: No data caps
- Service advantage: Symmetric speeds
- Service advantage: Growing coverage
Cons
- Limitation: Limited to Midwest/Southeast
- Limitation: Fewer plan options
- Limitation: New in many areas
Att: Internet service provider
Founded: N/A | Headquarters: N/A | Technology: Various
Plans & Pricing
Att offers Various-based internet service starting at Contact for pricing, with network infrastructure supporting speeds up to Varies. Their pricing philosophy reflects their internet service provider positioning, balancing affordability with performance capabilities. The provider's data policy of Check with provider shapes the real-world value proposition, especially for households with heavy streaming, gaming, or work-from-home requirements.
Pros
- Service advantage: Available in select markets
Cons
- Limitation: Limited availability information
Call Att: 1-855-850-5977
Speed Comparison: Technology Determines Performance
Maximum advertised speeds tell only part of the performance story. Metronet's Fiber network delivers up to 2 Gbps, while Att's Various infrastructure reaches Varies peak speeds. These numbers represent theoretical maximums under ideal conditions—real-world performance depends on network congestion, distance from network nodes, equipment quality, and time of day.
Upload speeds matter equally to downloads for modern internet usage. Video conferencing platforms like Zoom and Teams require 3-5 Mbps upload per HD stream, while cloud backup services and content creators need substantially more. Fiber technology typically delivers asymmetrical speeds with uploads running 5-10% of download speeds, while Various networks may offer better or similar upload performance depending on specific infrastructure implementation.
Network reliability and consistency separate providers as much as peak speeds. A gigabit connection that slows to 300 Mbps during evening hours provides worse real-world performance than a consistent 500 Mbps connection. Metronet's Fiber infrastructure generally maintains more consistent speeds throughout the day, particularly during peak usage windows between 7-11 PM when most households stream video and game online.
Latency (ping time) affects gaming, video calls, and real-time applications. Lower latency creates more responsive connections with less lag. Fiber networks typically achieve 20-40ms latency, while Various infrastructure may perform better or similarly depending on network architecture and distance to central offices. Serious gamers and professionals conducting frequent video meetings should prioritize consistent low-latency connections over peak speed numbers.
Pricing Breakdown: Understanding Total Monthly Costs
Advertised starting prices of $40/mo for Metronet and Contact for pricing for Att represent only promotional entry-level costs. Real monthly expenses include equipment rental ($10-15/mo for modems/routers), data overage charges if applicable, broadcast TV fees for bundles, and installation costs ($50-100 typically). Total costs over a two-year period differ substantially from promotional headlines.
Data caps significantly impact total monthly costs for moderate-to-heavy users. Metronet's policy of None means households exceeding included data pay additional charges, typically $10-15 per 50-100 GB overage block. Att's Check with provider policy requires similar consideration of usage patterns. A family streaming 200+ hours monthly can easily consume 500-800 GB, triggering substantial overages on capped plans.
Equipment fees add up over contract periods. Both providers charge $10-15 monthly for modem rentals unless you purchase compatible equipment ($120-200 for quality modems/routers). Over two years, rental fees total $240-360 versus one-time equipment purchases. However, provider-supplied equipment includes technical support and free replacements if hardware fails, while customer-owned equipment requires self-troubleshooting and replacement at your expense.
Promotional pricing expires after 12-24 months, typically increasing $10-25 monthly. Metronet implements smaller annual increases and offers price-lock guarantees on select plans, while Att increases rates more aggressively after promotional periods expire. Always calculate 24-month total costs including equipment, installation, and post-promotional rates when comparing true value.
Coverage & Availability: Service Area Determines Access
Metronet operates infrastructure primarily serving midwest/southeast users wanting pure fiber, concentrating network investments in specific geographic regions where their Fiber technology makes economic sense. Their footprint covers select markets where population density and competitive landscape justify infrastructure builds. This targeted approach means excellent service in covered areas but zero availability in adjacent communities.
Att focuses its Various network on users in service area, building infrastructure in markets matching their strategic priorities. Their coverage map reflects decades of incremental network expansion, acquisitions of smaller providers, and strategic decisions about where to deploy capital. Like most ISPs, they avoid low-density rural areas where infrastructure costs per subscriber make service unprofitable.
Overlap zones where both providers compete directly occur rarely, as most ISPs strategically avoid head-to-head competition except in high-value urban/suburban markets. When both serve the same address, Metronet generally provides superior value through better technology, more favorable policies, or competitive pricing pressure. However, verify actual service availability and technology type at your specific address before assuming coverage based on city-level maps.
Contract Terms & Fees: Understanding Service Agreements
Both Metronet and Att offer no-contract month-to-month service, providing flexibility to cancel anytime without early termination fees. This flexibility matters for renters, people planning to move, or households wanting to switch providers if better options become available. Month-to-month service eliminates the risk of $200-400 early termination fees when life circumstances change.
Promotional terms typically guarantee introductory rates for 12 months before resetting to standard pricing. During this period, Metronet charges their advertised $40/mo starting rate, while Att begins at Contact for pricing. After promotions expire, rates typically increase $10-25 monthly to standard pricing levels. Some providers offer price-lock guarantees extending beyond promotional periods, particularly in competitive markets where customer retention requires rate stability.
Standard fees apply across the industry: installation charges ($50-100 for professional setup, often waived with self-install), equipment rental ($10-15/mo for modems/routers), late payment fees ($8-10), paper billing surcharges ($5-10/mo unless you choose electronic billing), and service call charges ($70-100 for technician visits addressing non-provider equipment issues). Understanding these fees prevents billing surprises and allows accurate cost comparisons between providers.
Which Provider Should You Choose?
Choose Metronet if:
- You have access to their Fiber network at your address
- Your household uses 400+ GB monthly streaming, gaming, or downloading
- Consistent speeds during evening hours matter for your usage
- Upload performance matters for video calls or content creation
- You prefer midwest/southeast users wanting pure fiber
Choose Att if:
- Metronet isn't available at your specific address
- Your data usage stays reliably under included caps
- Their current promotional pricing beats Metronet by $15+/mo
- You specifically need users in service area
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use my own modem/router with these providers?
Most cable and fiber providers support customer-owned equipment, allowing you to avoid $10-15/mo rental fees. For Fiber networks like Metronet, purchase compatible modems ($120-180) from their approved equipment list. Various providers like Att may require specific equipment depending on technology type. Always verify compatibility before purchasing equipment, as providers only support troubleshooting for approved devices.
How do data caps affect my monthly costs?
Metronet implements None, while Att enforces Check with provider. Typical households consume 300-800 GB monthly through streaming video, gaming, video calls, and general browsing. Exceeding caps triggers overage charges of $10-15 per 50-100 GB block, potentially adding $40-100 to monthly bills. Unlimited data add-ons typically cost $25-30/mo extra.
Which provider offers better customer service?
Customer service quality varies significantly by market and individual experience. Check local reviews and ask neighbors about their experiences with Metronet and Att in your specific area. National customer satisfaction surveys provide general trends, but regional service quality depends on local technician teams and management. Both providers offer 24/7 phone support, online chat, and self-service portals for basic troubleshooting and account management.
Can I negotiate better rates with either provider?
Yes, internet providers regularly negotiate rates to retain customers, especially when promotional periods expire. Call customer retention departments before canceling and reference competitor offers at your address. Have specific pricing from alternatives ready to strengthen negotiation leverage. Providers often extend promotional rates another 6-12 months or offer bill credits ($10-30/mo) rather than lose customers. Loyalty matters less than competitive pressure—providers in competitive markets negotiate more freely.
What speeds do I actually need for my household?
Most households function well with 200-500 Mbps. Single users streaming HD video need 25-50 Mbps, while families with 3-5 people streaming 4K, gaming, and video conferencing simultaneously require 300-500 Mbps. Gigabit speeds (1000 Mbps) benefit large households (6+ people), 4K/8K content creators, or users downloading massive files regularly. Upload speeds matter equally for video calls (5 Mbps per HD stream) and cloud backups—consider Various networks for symmetrical upload performance if these activities dominate your usage.
How do I check actual availability at my address?
Use each provider's online address checker tool with your complete street address, not just ZIP code. Service varies block-by-block even within the same neighborhood due to infrastructure layouts. Provider coverage maps show general service areas but don't guarantee specific technology availability. Enter your exact address to confirm whether you'll receive Fiber, Various, or no service. If online tools show conflicting results, call providers directly to verify availability before making decisions.
What happens if service quality doesn't match promises?
Document performance issues with speed tests (Ookla, Fast.com) at different times across multiple days. Most providers guarantee speeds within 80-90% of advertised rates. If performance consistently falls short, contact customer support with documented evidence. Request technician visits to diagnose issues, which may involve signal strength problems, equipment failures, or network congestion. If problems persist unresolved, cite service level guarantees in your contract and request bill credits or early termination without fees.
Ready to get connected? Call now for exclusive deals:
1-855-981-6281Disclosure: InternetProviders.ai may earn a commission when you sign up for internet service through our links. Our recommendations are based on independent research and verified provider data, not commission rates. We are independently owned and operated.