Skip to main content
EarthLink logo

EarthLink

Internet service provider

vs
Optimum logo

Optimum

Internet service provider

EarthLink vs Optimum

Quick Answer

EarthLink vs Optimum: plans and advertised speeds in 2026. Compare the plans, contract terms, and data caps available at your address, then confirm current pricing.

By Pablo Mendoza, Lead Analyst

Compare speeds, pricing, coverage, and features, then check internet providers at your address to see which of the two is reported there.

Higher advertised speedNot available
More ZIP codes in coverage dataNot available

This page compares EarthLink and Optimum on plans, speeds, technology, contract terms, and data caps. Pricing and availability depend on your address, so confirm both before you order.

Ready to order?

Order online in a few minutes, or call to confirm pricing and availability at your address first.

Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you order through links on this page. Pricing, speeds, and availability vary by address and are subject to change; verify current terms with the provider before ordering.

Check availability at your address

See which of these providers — and others — actually serve your exact address, with real speeds and pricing from FCC broadband data.

Sponsored

Compare providers by ZIP

EarthLink vs Optimum: Key Findings

  • Check the speed tiers available at your address; maximum speed data is incomplete here
  • Check coverage at your address; coverage data is incomplete here
  • Technology: EarthLink uses Various, Optimum uses Various
  • Data caps: EarthLink — Varies; Optimum — Varies. Confirm the selected plan's policy

How EarthLink and Optimum Compare

EarthLink and Optimum are both major internet service providers, but they take different approaches to delivering broadband. Both providers use various technology, so the real differentiation comes down to pricing, plan options, and service quality in your area.

Check the download and upload speed tiers of the specific plans available at your address.

Confirm each selected plan’s contract and cancellation terms before ordering. Confirm each selected plan’s data cap and overage policy.

Check availability at your address

See which of these providers — and others — actually serve your exact address, with real speeds and pricing from FCC broadband data.

EarthLink markets internet service across the continental U.S. (48 states) using fiber, wireless and other technologies; the products available depend on the address. Optimum is the consumer brand of Optimum Communications, Inc. It is launching fiber-to-the-home service community by community, so Optimum service at a given address is not necessarily fiber, and its footprint is not limited to the Northeast.

EarthLink vs Optimum: Side-by-Side Comparison
FeatureEarthLinkOptimum
Max Speed5 Gbps8 Gbps
Starting Price$50/moReference price — verify for your addressReference price — verify for your address
TechnologyFiber, DSL, Fixed WirelessCable, Fiber (FTTH)
ContractsNoNo
Data CapsNoNo

EarthLink vs Optimum: Provider Details

EarthLink and Optimum provider details side-by-side
DetailEarthLinkOptimum
Primary TechnologyFiber, DSL, Fixed WirelessCable, Fiber (FTTH)
Top Speed (Down/Up)5 Gbps8 Gbps
CoverageNational — 48 statesRegional — 4 states
ContractNo contractNo contract
Data CapsNoneNone
HeadquartersAtlanta, GeorgiaLong Island City, New York
Notable FeaturesMultiple technology optionsNo contracts • Optimum Mobile bundling

EarthLink Service & Install

Customer service: Mon-Fri 8AM-11PM ET, Sat-Sun 8AM-10PM ET; US-based customer support; online chat available

Installation: Professional installation available (varies by technology). Fiber installation requires technician visit. DSL self-install kits available. Fixed wireless gateway ships with easy setup guide.

Optimum Service & Install

Customer service: 24/7 customer support by phone; Optimum stores in NY/NJ/CT open Mon-Sat; Optimum app for billing & self-service

Installation: Free professional installation on most plans. Self-install kit available for cable at existing Optimum locations. Fiber installation requires technician visit (2-3 hours). Appointments within 3-5 business days.

Plans Compared: EarthLink vs Optimum

Verified monthly pricing and typical download speeds for each provider's residential plans, sourced from their FCC broadband label filings. Promotional and address-specific pricing may vary.

EarthLink plans

EarthLink internet plans and pricing
PlanSpeedPrice
Fiber 100100 Mbps$54.95/mo
Fiber 300300 Mbps$59.95/mo
Fiber 500500 Mbps$69.95/mo
Fiber 1 Gig1 Gbps$79.95/mo
Fiber 2 Gig2 Gbps$99.95/mo
Fiber 5 Gig5 Gbps$154.95/mo
See all EarthLink plans & pricing

Optimum plans

Optimum internet plans and pricing
PlanSpeedPrice
Bayonne Nj 300 Mbps Internet328 Mbps$45/mo
300 Mbps Fiber Internet365 Mbps$45/mo
500 Mbps Fiber Internet566 Mbps$65/mo
Bayonne Nj 500 Mbps Internet542 Mbps$65/mo
Cable 1 Gig Internet1.0 Gbps$65/mo
1 Gig Fiber Internet1.2 Gbps$65/mo
See all Optimum plans & pricing

Head-to-Head Comparison

EarthLink vs Optimum feature comparison
FeatureEarthLinkOptimumComparison
Max SpeedVariesVariesNot available
Coverage (ZIP Codes)Not available4,117Not available
Primary TechnologyVariousVariousDepends on needs
Contract RequiredNot availableNot availableNot available
Data CapNot availableNot availableNot available

Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you order through links on this page. Pricing, speeds, and availability vary by address and are subject to change; verify current terms with the provider before ordering.

Pros & Cons

EarthLink

Pros

    Cons

      Optimum

      Pros

        Cons

          Which Provider Should You Choose?

          Choose EarthLink if:

          • EarthLink is available at your address

          Choose Optimum if:

          • Optimum is available at your address

          The Bottom Line

          Compare the plans, contract terms, and data caps available at your address, then confirm current pricing.

          Confirm Availability and Current Offers

          Ask about service at your address and what the final order terms include.

          Third-party tracked sales lines • Not provider support • Confirm availability and final terms before ordering

          Frequently Asked Questions

          Which is faster, EarthLink or Optimum?
          Check the download and upload speeds of the specific plans offered by EarthLink and Optimum at your address before choosing a plan.
          Which is cheaper, EarthLink or Optimum?
          Starting prices for EarthLink and Optimum change with promotions and vary by plan, equipment fees, and address, so there is no single answer. Enter your address to see current plans and prices from each provider, then compare the total monthly cost of the speed tier you need.
          Do EarthLink and Optimum have data caps?
          Check the selected EarthLink plan for its data cap policy. Check the selected Optimum plan for its data cap policy. Confirm the policy for the specific plan available at your address.
          Do EarthLink or Optimum require a contract?
          Confirm the selected plan's contract length and cancellation terms with EarthLink and Optimum before ordering.
          Is EarthLink or Optimum faster?
          Compare the download and upload speeds of the specific plans available from EarthLink and Optimum at your address.
          Which is better, EarthLink or Optimum?
          EarthLink uses Various and Optimum uses Various. Compare the speed tier, data cap, contract terms, and current price of the plans available at your address to choose the provider that fits your household.
          Can I get EarthLink and Optimum at the same address?
          Availability depends on your location. Check EarthLink and Optimum at your exact address before comparing their available plans. Technology type alone does not confirm that both providers serve your home.
          Should I choose EarthLink or Optimum?
          The best choice depends on your priorities. Consider current pricing at your address, data caps, contract requirements, technology type, and availability when making your decision.

          Sources & Methodology

          This EarthLink vs Optimum comparison uses coverage data from FCC Broadband Data Collection filings and plan, price and speed details from provider broadband labels where available, otherwise from the plan details we list for each provider. Pricing, speeds, and availability vary by location, so confirm them with the provider before ordering. For a detailed explanation of our data collection and scoring process, see our methodology page.

          InternetProviders.ai is an independent resource. We may earn commissions from partner links. Commissions never change a provider's rating or the plan facts we list. See our methodology for details.

          Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, June 2025

          Check Availability at Your Address

          Enter your ZIP code to see if EarthLink or Optimum is available